ResourceShelf.com directed me to this article.


Title: Google Scholar: the pros and the cons
Author(s): Péter Jacsó
Journal: Online Information Review
Year: 2005 Volume: 29 Number: 2 Page: 208 -- 214
DOI: 10.1108/14684520510598066
It is available free online this week ONLY (week of May 23, 2005)

Abstract:
Purpose - To identify the pros and the cons of Google Scholar. Design/methodology/approach - Chronicles the recent history of the Google Scholar search engine from its inception in November 2004 and critiques it with regard to its merits and demerits. Findings - Feels that there are massive content omissions presently but that, with future changes in its structure, Google Scholar will become an excellent free tool for scholarly information discovery and retrieval. Originality/value - Presents a useful analysis for potential users of the Google Scholar site.